Yesterday, working with the heavy horses and discussing the belief – still very much current – that chesnuts are a “bad colour” and chesnut mares in particular are mardy cows, I was thinking about horse colour lore in general, and then of the famous (to some of us) quote from the Horsemen:
‘Here’s to the horse with the four white feet,
the chestnut tail and mane;
a star on his face and a spot on his breast,
and his master’s name was Cain.’
This suddenly struck me pretty hard. Obviously the saying has more obvious esoteric meanings, but in light of its origins, I found myself considering in terms of the horseman’s lore that is still current and stretches back, consistently, for centuries (we can find it well-established in William Gibson’s writing in the 1700s, for example).
Like I say, chesnut (as it’s traditionally spelled by horsemen and -women) is pretty universally considered to be a “bad colour”, along with colours like roan (superstitiously considered neurotic and flighty and “unlucky”, though often considered to be good doers) – though of course, as the saying goes, “a good horse is never a bad colour” – and the lore of markings, again still very much active, comes in here too. I was very much brought up with the old saying about white socks – “One buy him, two try him, three suspect him, four reject him”*
So Cain’s Horse is of an unlucky, ill-natured colour, and with one of the most universally despised markings, the unlucky four white feet! (The only thing that could be more ill-favoured would be if the saying was “legs” and not feet, because that might imply that the legs showed the hated “high white” markings, extending above the knee/hock.)
Now, leaving aside its mystical meanings, a facial star is generally considered a positive thing, a beautiful and “lucky” marking, so long as it’s not too large.
The spot on the chest carries less lore, besides the fact that white body markings are generally viewed with suspicion by the upper classes as being too close to ‘coloured horses’ (skewbalds and piebalds) with their working class and “gypsy horse” connotations.**
Something worth noting here is that white markings on the body are particularly common in Clydesdales, one of the main working/draught breeds here in the UK – particularly in Scotland – and Clydesdales are also known for having white socks. And horses can end up with white marks from pressure – something I’ve particularly observed in working/draught horses.
Since Cain is the First Farmer, it makes sense that his Horse (whatever else it is in occult terms) is a working horse, the plough horse whose draught-pole is the stang. Note that this is one of the literal meanings of “stang” in Scots: it’s a generic term for a wooden bar or pole, but one of the specific meanings is just that, the shaft or draught-pole of a cart. And if the stang is the draught-pole, and the stang of the Craft is double-ended, then we are reminded of the Chariot of the tarot, the two horses of will and passion, divine and animal nature, morality and appetite, dating back to Plato’s chariot allegory.
And so Cain’s Horse, with its lucky star and unlucky white feet, its “bad colour” that is none the less toasted by the company, and its white mark of work, embodies in itself the stang, the Chariot and the double-natured Craft: lucky and unlucky, straight and twisted, as divine and devilish as the Witch Himself.
Ploughing, William Crawford
—
* another familiar form of this saying, which shows up in various forms, is:
If you have a horse with four white feet, keep him not a day
If you have a horse with three white feet, send him far away
If you have a horse with two white feet, give him to a friend
If you have a horse with one white foot, keep him to the end.
** Modern chesnuts may show what are known as “birdcatcher marks” if they’re descended from the TB of that name, but this is unlikely to have affected the relevant lore, since he lived in the 1800s and Cain’s Horse is, given the context of the Horsemen, unlikely to have been a TB! – though you never know. Other causes of white spotting in chesnuts can be a copper deficiency (possible in working horses) and equine vitiligo, the so-called “arab fading syndrome” (since it shows up in that breed a lot).